Buy a car
from the safety of your home.
Connect with our dealer and finance partners through our site and ask for details regarding their at-home car buying services.
  • Video car tours
  • E-transaction: complete paperwork online
  • Vehicle home delivery
  • Enhanced vehicle sanitization
OK

Review update: 2020 Toyota Prius Prime excels at efficiency, little else

August 27, 2020

The 2020 Toyota Prius Prime is a plug-in electric version of Toyota’s bestselling hybrid. It gets 25 miles of quiet electric range, and when that juice runs out it still gets 54 mpg, according to the EPA. The Prius Prime outdoes the Hyundai Ioniq plug-in to reign as fuel-efficiency champ. For now. 

But with more plug-in hybrids and electric vehicles coming to market, the Prius and its variants are no longer at the vanguard of green cars. The Hyundai Ioniq outdoes the Prius Even in Toyota’s family, the RAV4 Hybrid crossover SUV outsold the Prius in 2019 to stake claim as the biggest seller. The 2021 RAV4 Hybrid rates 40 mpg combined, but it’s better than the Prius in every other category, especially design. The 2020 Toyota Prius earns a TCC Rating of 6.0 out of 10. 

The RAV4 Prime plug-in hybrid promises to outdo the Prius Prime, once Toyota corrects the fuel tank issue that limits being able to fill the tank to the brim.

Yet, in a week around town and on the highway with the 2020 Toyota Prius Prime in top Limited trim, it proved worthy of consideration for urbanites with access to a plug.  

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

Hit: Marginal mark up, hidden deal

At $34,605, including $995 destination in top Limited trim, the 2020 Toyota Prius Prime only costs about $1,000 more than the 2020 Prius Limited at $33,645. The 8.8-kwh battery pack qualifies it for a $4,502 federal EV tax credit, as long as your income qualifies. That brings it down to $30,000, which is cheaper than the Prius Limited. The 2021 RAV4 Prime qualifies for the full $7,500 tax credit, which brings its starting price down to about $32,000 for some buyers.

Hit/Miss: Daring to be different

For 20 years, the Prius has weathered the scorn of aesthetes who think a car should look less like a pod. Relaunched for 2017, the Prius Prime is four inches longer than the Prius to look more like a sedan and less like a pod. The rear is less bulbous, but the split rear windshield curves up in the middle like a set of lips. I imagine owners eventually get used to it in their rearview mirrors. The big change for 2020 comes on the inside, which now seats five passengers instead of four. Three rear passengers can sit stiffly over the 8.8-kwh battery pack housed beneath the seat. Inside, the Prius eschews an instrument cluster for a display wedged at the top center of the dash where the cowl meets the windshield. An 11.6-inch touchscreen dominates the cockpit like a Tesla but with...

Miss: ...Limited functionality

Tesla, Toyota is not. The portrait orientation is bright and clear and defaults to a map view with a little Prius on top of the map world. A split screen at the bottom grows as you press the climate or audio function. Hard temperature buttons on the sides of the screen help, and overall it’s an improvement in an area Toyota has historically lagged in, but it’s far from great. Four circular icons overlap the map projection for deeper dives, but there’s greater accuracy hitting the home screen button instead of trying to tap on those four icons. The system can lag, and I had mixed success in hitting the intended buttons while driving. Navigation is best left to Apple CarPlay; sorry, Android users, no dice. Toyota’s voice command fidelity is awful; “north” was processed as “four” and “address” was heard as “state.”

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

Hit: Efficient

The Prius Prime excels at what it was meant to do: squeeze every bit of juice out of every drop of energy. It defaults to EV mode for 25 miles of electric range, even at speeds up to 75 mph. An EV/Hybrid mode button makes sense for highway traveling, when the 95-horsepower 1.8-liter inline-4 operates most efficiently, but there is no EV Hold button as in other plug-in hybrids that helps preserve battery power until you get off the highway. A more aggressive regen braking setting on the gear shifter recovers more energy, even when the battery is depleted. On a 300-mile road trip, starting with only 25 miles of range, it averaged 65 mpg. On a mixed commute of 57 miles, it averaged 75 mpg. In other instances where I had no battery power, it exceeded the EPA-rated 54 mpg. A similarly equipped Prius gets 52 mpg.

Miss: Quiet riot

As long as it’s under electric power, it’s quiet. Go heavy on the throttle at an on ramp, say, and the small engine roars like an environmentalist at a forest clearing. In Hybrid mode, it’s silent traveling slower than 20 mph and gradually intensifies with more engine power. It’s enough to make you want to stay in electric power.

All that potential noise is nothing compared to the reverse BEEP BEEP BEEP. For safety reasons, in case that backward sensation fooled you for vertigo, Toyota decided to make the most obnoxious beep this side of a car alarm. It made me try to find clever ways to avoid backing up; sorry to my neighbor’s lawn. One passenger keen on the fuel economy said, “There’s too much, what is that, why does it, I could never buy this car.” Because of a beeping beep.

The 2020 Prius Prime is a relative bargain when it comes to fuel economy. There are better, roomier, more attractive plug-in hybrids (see the RAV4 Prime), but the Prius Prime stretches more miles to the gallon than its rivals. 

_______________________________________

2020 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

Base price: $34,605, including $995 destination

Price as tested: $35,536

Drivetrain: 1.8-liter inline-4 with eCVT in front-wheel drive

EPA fuel economy: 54 mpg combined on gas only, 133 mpge, 25-mile electric range

The hits: Value, efficiency. 

The misses: Loud, obnoxious, improved tech that still misses the mark.

2020
The Car Connection
See the winners »
2020
The Car Connection
 
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from The Car Connection. I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.