American brands take 11 of bottom 12 spots in Consumer Reports reliability survey

October 29, 2018

American brands such as General Motors, Ford, Fiat Chrysler, and even Tesla had a rough showing in the results of Consumer Reports annual reliability survey released last week, which gathered data on half a million vehicles this year.

Volvo was dead last in 29th place, but every American marque occupied the next 11 worse spots, from Cadillac at 28th to Ford at 18th. For the second year in a row, Lexus and Toyota took the top two spots respectively, though the two brands switched places this year.

MORE: Tesla Model S, Honda Odyssey and more lose Consumer Reports recommendation

Volvo’s reliability issues stem almost entirely from the brand's Sensus infotainment system, which uses an iPad-sized screen in the dashboard to control almost all of the vehicle’s important functions, including climate control. The S90 sedan also experienced engine knocking according to some customers.

A surprising result was Tesla in 27th place, plagued by suspension problems on the Model S and many issues with the Model X including the infotainment screen and “falcon” doors. Buick had the biggest fall from grace, dropping 11 spots from last year to 19th place, mostly for issues with the 9-speed automatic transmission in the new Enclave SUV.

Mazda had the biggest jump, moving up 9 spots from last year after ironing out issues with models like the CX-9 crossover SUV and MX-5 Miata roadster. The top four brands were all Japanese, and German brands lined the middle of the pack with Audi highest at 7th and Mercedes-Benz lowest at 17th.

The list didn’t include Alfa Romeo, Fiat, Jaguar, Land Rover, Maserati, Mitsubishi, or Smart for a lack of usable data, though Consumer Reports mentioned that Alfa Romeo Giulia owners have experienced much worse than average reliability, and Jaguar F-Pace owners have also had sub-par reliability, thanks in part to infotainment issues.

The full ranking can be found below:

  1. Lexus

  2. Toyota

  3. Mazda

  4. Subaru

  5. Kia

  6. Infiniti

  7. Audi

  8. BMW

  9. Mini

  10. Hyundai

  11. Porsche

  12. Genesis

  13. Acura

  14. Nissan

  15. Honda

  16. Volkswagen

  17. Mercedes-Benz

  18. Ford

  19. Buick

  20. Lincoln

  21. Dodge

  22. Jeep

  23. Chevrolet

  24. Chrysler

  25. GMC

  26. Ram

  27. Tesla

  28. Cadillac

  29. Volvo

The Car Connection
See the winners »
The Car Connection
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from The Car Connection. I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.