2017 Subaru BRZ vs. 2017 Toyota 86: Compare Cars

October 17, 2016
2016 Scion FR-S

2016 Scion FR-S

Enlarge Photo

If you want a sporty car and aren't into muscle-car poses and smoky burnouts, there really aren't many no-frills rear-wheel-drive coupes. But two of the best possibilities left are ones you'll almost certainly want to consider: the Subaru BRZ and the Toyota 86. 

What's that, you say? They're the same car? Close. They're really similar, but each has a slightly different personality. 

Truth be told, we score them almost the same. The BRZ wins, by a hair, because it comes in more flavors and offers a package with special shocks and brakes. If you're interested in performance—and you are if you're reading this—you'll understand the BRZ's 6.5 overall versus the 86's 6.3. (Read more about how we rate cars.)

But which one should you drive--the 86 or the BRZ?

MORE: Read our latest reviews of the 2017 Toyota 86 and 2017 Subaru BRZ

The 86 and BRZ are near-twins, developed and designed by a joint effort between Subaru and Toyota. Aside from some differences in design and equipment, they're functionally the same car. Oh, and until last year, the 86 was known as the Scion FR-S, but that brand was dissolved and its products were assimilated into the Toyota lineup. That said, there's more than just a name change here, as both the 86 and the BRZ received a modest update for the 2017 model year focused primarily on improving their handling.

2017 Toyota 86

2017 Toyota 86

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota 86

2017 Toyota 86

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota 86

2017 Toyota 86

Enlarge Photo

The gap between the two has narrowed, with the BRZ taking on some of the former FR-S' more tail-happy nature. You'll have to drive the back-to-back on a winding road or a closed course to really tell the differences, but one place where they diverge big time for 2017 is in the loaded-up BRZ Limited with the Performance Package. That's the spec it takes to get specially-tuned Sachs ZF shocks, Brembo brakes, wider alloy wheels, and wider tires. 

Previously, we found that the Scion FR-S would demonstrate a slightly (but noticeably to those with a nose for it) greater willingness to rotate—that is, to move around its central axis. But for 2017, the gap between the two is smaller thanks to a host of delicate suspension revisions. Both are about as much fun as you can have behind the wheel of a sub-$30,000 sports car, assuming that drag racing isn't your goal. 

The nitty-gritty

Aesthetically, the BRZ and 86 both convey a sense of friendly, sporty attitude. Low-slung, with curving roof lines and slightly flared fenders, you'd be forgiven for not noticing the differences straight away. Up front, the 86 and BRZ wear slightly different bumpers, the primary difference being the shape of the grille opening. Of course each also gets its brand-specific badges, but beyond that, there are essentially. Even inside their cabins, the differences are limited to upholstery and stitching. 

That's not a bad thing, however, as Subaru and Toyota have managed to pack in a lot of value for not much money—though again, here we have a difference. A minor reshuffling for 2017 means that the BRZ now starts less than the 86 (the FR-S was slightly cheaper). That's mostly because the BRZ Premium lacks automatic climate control. Can you live with manual climate control? You'll save $800 or so off the bat by shopping at your local Subaru dealer. But the BRZ wins more points since its Limited trim grade adds the aforementioned automatic climate plus heated seats, leather trim, and upgraded interior materials. And it's the Limited that offers the Performance Package with its goodies, although you're perilously close to $30,000 at that point.

2017 Subaru BRZ

2017 Subaru BRZ

Enlarge Photo
2017 Subaru BRZ

2017 Subaru BRZ

Enlarge Photo
2017 Subaru BRZ

2017 Subaru BRZ

Enlarge Photo

Underneath, they're essentially the same, save for some minor suspension differences. Both utilize a 2.0-liter boxer (horizontally-opposed) four-cylinder engine with combination port and direct injection. The engine is rated at 205 horsepower and 156 pound-feet of torque. That's not a lot, but these models are less about straight-line speed or acceleration than what it does when the road bends. A 6-speed manual is standard and a 6-speed automatic optional on both, although you'll have to get the stick if you want the base BRZ as the automatic is a Limited-only item.

Both the BRZ and FR-S are also rated at 21 mpg city, 28 highway, 24 combined with a manual transmission, and a considerably better 24/32/27 with an automatic.

Inside, both cars are surprisingly well-finished considering their performance and price. While there are no expanses of semi-aniline leather, there are pleasing matte-finish trim pieces, soft-touch plastics, and a simple, purposeful design theme that suits the spirit of the car: no-nonsense sporting fun. The rear seats are even somewhat useful; full-size adults won't want to go cross-country in the back, but they won't mind going across town. Both have different infotainment systems, and neither are exactly class-leading in that regard. There's no navigation on the BRZ, but a Toyota dealer can add navigation to the 86 for $900 plus any installation fees. Or, you could just use your cell phone.  

The bottom line with either the Toyota 86 or Subaru BRZ is that you can't go wrong, whichever brand you choose, as they're the two newest, and in our eyes, best, entrants to the (mostly) under-$30,000 sports car market. Frankly, it may come down to which dealership offers the better experience.

___________________________________________

Follow The Car Connection on Facebook and Twitter.

Summary

6.3
Expert Rating
The 2017 Toyota 86 isn't about power, but it is about fun, and it has just enough creature comforts to make it livable as a daily driver.
6.5
Expert Rating
The 2017 Subaru BRZ is a great-handling sports car with big value for the dollar; it's just not very fast.

Styling

7.0
Expert Rating
The 2017 Toyota 86 is long, low, and sleek like a sports car should be, but it's not as sexy as its mission suggests.
Read More
7.0
Expert Rating
A classic 2-door shape and a wraparound cockpit give the Subaru BRZ its crisp sports-car looks.
Read More

Performance

7.0
Expert Rating
Affordable and nimble, the Toyota 86 is a blast to drive and it has reachable real-world handling limits.
Read More
7.0
Expert Rating
Acceleration is average, but it's delightful handling that keeps us in the BRZ's fan base.
Read More

Comfort & Quality

6.0
Expert Rating
Room up front is good and the 86 has a large trunk, but the rear seat is tiny. Still, that's about the best you can expect from a sports coupe.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
Two passengers will appreciate the BRZ's cozy cockpit; everything else is an afterthought.
Read More

Safety

6.0
Expert Rating
Crash-test ratings are incomplete, but the FR-S ratings were mostly good; the 86 lacks today's active safety features.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
Safety in the BRZ is below average by Subaru standards, fine by the absolutes.
Read More

Features

6.0
Expert Rating
Toyota keeps the 86's feature set basic, but buyers can get a navigation system and a host of dealer-installed accessories.
Read More
7.0
Expert Rating
The BRZ doesn't offer much in the way of extravagant options and features.
Read More

Fuel Economy

6.0
Expert Rating
Power is best tapped into at high rpms, which means everyday fuel economy is pretty good.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
The BRZ has fairly good ratings by the EPA, particularly the automatic. But who wants that?
Read More

MSRP

from $26,255
from $25,495

Invoice

from $24,943
from $24,327

Fuel Economy - Combined City and Highway

24
24

Engine

Premium Unleaded H-4, 2.0 L
Premium Unleaded H-4, 2.0 L

Drivetrain

Rear Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Rear Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Compare Free Dealer Price Quote
With competitive price quotes from multiple dealers, you will be prepared when you meet your local car dealer. Please tell us how to contact you so that dealers can compete for your business!
Search Dealers by ZIP Code
Update ZIP Code
2017 Toyota 86
2017 Subaru BRZ
Looking for dealers in your area...
Powered By
We are committed to your privacy. By submitting this form you agree the phone number you provided may be used to contact you (including text, autodialed or pre-recorded calls). Consent is not a condition of purchase.
2018
The Car Connection
See the winners »
2018
The Car Connection
 
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
Related Head to Head
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.