Midsize Sedans Earn Low Ratings In Fender-Bender Tests

August 7, 2009
mazda 6 frankfurt 005

mazda 6 frankfurt 005

A couple of months ago, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety conducted fender-bender tests on a handful of minicars and subcompacts. The results weren't encouraging, with most scoring poorly, and only a few landing in the "acceptable" range. Now, the IIHS has conducted a second battery of tests -- this time on midsize sedans -- and unfortunately, the majority of those underperformed expectations, too.

Models tested included the 2009 Honda Accord, the 2009 Hyundai Sonata, the 2009 Mazda 6, and 2009 Nissan Maxima. According to the IIHS, each of those models showed improvement over its 2007 version, but none earned a rating of "good", based on repair costs associated with low-speed crash tests. The IIHS conducted four such tests with models -- front full, front corner, rear full, and rear corner -- then calculated repair costs for each crash and a weighted average for all four. To earn a rating of "good", the average repair cost needed to clock in at $500 or below. The closest any model came to that was the Mazda 6, with an "acceptable" $871 average repair bill.

Further down the chart, the Honda Accord and Hyundai Sonata ranked "marginal", at $1133 and $1265, respectively. Over $1,500 meant a ranking of "poor", and that's where we find the Nissan Maxima ($1,687), Ford Fusion ($2,207), and Chevrolet Malibu ($2,329). All the way at the bottom: the Pontiac G6, with repair bill that averaged just shy of $3,000.  In all, 17 models were tested, 11 of which received "poor" ratings; check the full results by clicking here.

While the improvement of the 2009 models seems promising, it's clear that automakers still have a long way to go in making vehicles easy to maintain (and insure). Then again, there are some who have a vested interest in keeping those repair bills high. So, question of the day: is this a problem? And if so, what's the solution?

[Edmunds, IIHS]

The Car Connection
See the winners »
The Car Connection
Commenting is closed for this article
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from The Car Connection. I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.