2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class Review

Consumer Reviews
0 Reviews
2018
The Car Connection
See the nominees and vote »
2018
The Car Connection

The Car Connection Expert Review

Marty Padgett Marty Padgett Editorial Director
March 6, 2010

You wanted a Mercedes minivan? The 2010 R-Class crossover is as close as you'll get, down to the driving feel.

If car companies treated their products like TV families, Mercedes-Benz would have a Brady-style dilemma on its hands with the R-Class. It's such a Jan-the obedient, plain B student unfortunately born between two cuter, smarter, more talented siblings. The R-Class all but disappeared in the shadows of the five-seat ML-Class and seven-seater GL-Class sport-utes from the day it was born in 2006, and it hasn't made a dent in the luxury-crossover market since, even though a diesel engine makes it the most efficient vehicle of its kind. Radical change isn't coming any time soon, either. For 2010, the R-Class gets very few tweaks-the biggest one in name only-and soldiers on with a price tag of about $50,000. The crossovers it gets jealous of? The big and bawdy Lincoln MKT, the lean and sophisticated Audi Q7, and the poster child for the bling generation, the Cadillac Escalade.

The R-Class is sidelined most, we think, because of its inflated proportions. It's the rare car that looks bigger than it is. We don't find anything wrong with the details of the R-Class, but it tries to fuse a sport-ute personality on a minivan-sized body and misses the mark. As long as an S-Class and as tall as some SUVs, the R-Class just can't hide its bulk behind the mom-jeans effect of a low, aerodynamic nose. Worse yet, at first glance, you might mistake it for its old corporate cousin, the Chrysler Pacifica. Inside, it's plainer than you might expect, and the R-Class dash reads more "utility" than it does "luxury." Wide bands of wood trim dress up the gray plastics well enough, and gauges have cut-tube styling that's trendy and handsome. It's the big stack of controls between front passengers and the oddly retro chrome trim on the steering wheel that dial back the luxe look the most. You'd find the same shapes in minivans of a lesser price point.

For 2010, two R-Class models wear the alphanumeric R350 tag-despite the fact that the diesel version displaces just 3.0 liters. The diesel turns the R-Class into a very practical utility vehicle; it's as smooth as modern diesels get, and though its output is rated at just 210 horsepower, its big torque figure of 400 pound-feet gets channeled through a seven-speed automatic and an all-wheel-drive system for relatively swift acceleration, all-weather grip, and a wallet-friendly 18/24 mpg fuel economy rating. The gas-powered 3.5-liter V-6 puts out 268 hp through the same transmission and AWD system, giving the R-Class a little more straight-line performance while cutting fuel economy to 14/19 mpg. Benz estimates either version will accelerate to 60 mph in about 8.0 seconds. The R-Class' gearbox is a smooth operator, and it offers a manual-shift mode-but we're not sure many drivers ever will use it. The R-Class' 5,000-pound body and sluggish steering will smother most attempts at brisk driving on curvy roads, even if the powerful brakes can keep up their end of the bargain. The R-Class' air suspension damps most bumps out of touch, though like the GL-Class SUV, its roll control is so tight passengers will feel more head toss than in a softly sprung Cadillac Escalade. Both 2010 R350 crossovers will tow 3,500 pounds with an optional hitch.

Review continues below

Whether it's a sport tourer, a crossover, or a pseudo-minivan, one thing's for sure: The R-Class delivers its passengers in more comfort and space than any truck-based SUV, and it's on a par with TheCarConnection's favorite big crossovers, the Ford Flex and Lincoln MKT. The R-Class seats six or seven passengers, and at least four of them will be coddled in supreme comfort all of the time. All three pairs of seats are full-sized and offer adult-sized cushioning and headroom. A third passenger seat can be fitted in the second row in the place of a console. The third-row seats are nearly as plush, with a touch less knee room and width, and they're easily accessed from the R-Class' wide rear doors and easy-tilt second-row seats. Those big doors can be difficult to open in crowded parking lots, even in generous spaces. The second and third rows of seats fold down to create a sizable cargo space of about 87 cubic feet (a huge 50 cubic feet shy of the Escalade ESV, but larger and flatter than the space in the Lincoln MKT), and the R-Class is positively littered with in-cabin storage, molded into the door panels and hidden under console lids.

The 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class has better safety protection than even last year's model. A new POST-SAFE system disables electrical and fuel systems after an accident, while PRE-SAFE tightens seatbelts in advance of an accident. All R-Class crossovers have anti-lock brakes; traction and stability control; four-wheel drive; dual front, front and rear side, and side curtain airbags that cover the third seating row; active headrests; a trailer-sway control system; and tire pressure monitors. A radar-based cruise control system, parking sensors, and a rearview camera are options. The IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety) gives the R-Class "good" ratings for front and side impact protection; NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration) has not tested the R-Class.

Mercedes simplifies some R-Class equipment and options for 2010. All R350 crossovers get standard vinyl upholstery; wood trim; a sunroof (on gas versions); a leather-trimmed steering wheel; 19-inch wheels; power front seats; dual-zone automatic climate control; power windows, mirrors, and locks; COMAND control for audio and entertainment systems; an AM/FM/DVD changer with SD memory slot and an auxiliary jack; and Bluetooth. An iPod/MP3 interface, Sirius Satellite Radio with real-time traffic and data, and HD Radio are options, along with a rear-seat entertainment system. Other options include a power liftgate; keyless entry and push-button start; a cargo tray; a seven-seat configuration; parking sensors; ventilated seats; a panoramic sunroof; a towing package; a heating steering wheel; and heated front seats. Twenty-inch wheels can be fitted to gas-powered versions.

7

2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class

Styling

The 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class won't drive any enthusiast mad with desire.

The R-Class never has been a strong seller, and without a major styling change for 2010, it's likely to remain the invisible cousin to the crisp, good-looking Benz ML-Class and GL-Class SUVs.

The R-Class gets sidelined from most shopping lists, we think, because of its inflated proportions. We don't find anything wrong with the details of the R-Class, but it tries to impose a sport-ute personality on a minivan-sized body and misses the mark. As long as an S-Class and as tall as some SUVs, the R-Class just can't hide its bulk behind the mom-jeans effect of a low, aerodynamic nose. Also, it looks vaguely like many vehicles, and none of the comparisons would be taken as compliments in Stuttgart. At first glance, you might mistake it for its old corporate cousin, the Chrysler Pacifica.

Inside, the R-Class is plainer than you might expect, and it reads more "utility" than "luxury." Wide bands of wood trim dress up the gray plastics well enough, and gauges have cut-tube styling that's trendy and handsome. It's the big stack of controls between front passengers and the chrome trim on the steering wheel that dial back the luxe look the most. You'd find the same shapes in minivans of a lesser price point.

More Opinions:
Car and Driver: "sensuous curves"
Cars.com: "rounded and squat at the rear, the R-Class flaunts a relatively long profile"
Edmunds: interior is "both posh and functional"

7

2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class

Performance

It's not particularly quick or nimble, but diesel power gives the R-Class a leg up on fuel economy.

Two engines give the 2010 R-Class nearly identical performance numbers, save for the very important number from the EPA: fuel economy.

For 2010, two R-Class models wear the alphanumeric R350 tag-despite the fact that the diesel version displaces just 3.0 liters. The diesel turns the R-Class into a very practical utility vehicle; it's as smooth as modern diesels get, and though its output is rated at just 210 horsepower, its big torque figure of 400 pound-feet gets channeled through a seven-speed automatic and an all-wheel-drive system for relatively swift acceleration, all-weather grip, and a wallet-friendly 18/24 mpg fuel economy rating.

The gas-powered 3.5-liter V-6 puts out 268 hp through the same transmission and AWD system, giving the R-Class a little more straight-line performance while cutting fuel economy to 14/19 mpg. Mercedes estimates either version takes about 8 seconds to cruise to 60 mph from a full stop.

The R-Class' gearbox is a smooth operator, and it offers a manual-shift mode-but we're not sure many drivers ever will use it. The R-Class' 5,000-pound body and sluggish steering will smother most attempts at brisk driving on curvy roads, even if the powerful brakes can keep up their end of the bargain. The R-Class' air suspension damps most bumps out of touch, though like the GL-Class SUV, its roll control is so tight passengers will feel more head toss than in a softly sprung Cadillac Escalade.

Both 2010 R350 crossovers will tow 3,500 pounds with an optional hitch.

More Opinions
Edmunds: diesel "really lunges forward once the Bluetec is on boil"
ConsumerGuide: diesel "suffers brief turbo lag, then accelerates quickly"
Kelley Blue Book: "seamless shifts, always finding just the right gear when needed"
Cars.com: "steering feels just right for this new class of car"
ConsumerGuide: "acts more like a station wagon than an SUV"
ConsumerGuide: "the steering is impressively linear and accurate, though some drivers may prefer a weightier feel"

9

2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class

Comfort & Quality

There's no shortage of passenger or cargo room inside the 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class.

Whether it's a sport tourer, a crossover, or a pseudo-minivan, one thing's for sure: The R-Class delivers its passengers in more comfort and space than any truck-based SUV, and it's on a par with TheCarConnection.com's favorite big crossovers, the Ford Flex and Lincoln MKT.

The R-Class seats six or seven passengers, and at least four of them will be coddled in supreme comfort all of the time. All three pairs of seats are full-sized and offer adult-sized cushioning and headroom. A third passenger seat can be fitted in the second row in the place of a console, but it might not fit larger folks. The third-row seats are nearly as plush, with a touch less knee room and width, and they're easily accessed from the R-Class' wide rear doors and easy-tilt second-row seats. Those big doors can be difficult to open in crowded parking lots, even in generous spaces.

The second and third rows of seats fold down to create a vast cargo space of about 87 cubic feet (a huge 50 cubic feet shy of the Escalade ESV, but larger and flatter than the Lincoln MKT), and the R-Class is positively littered with in-cabin storage, molded into the door panels and hidden under console lids.

You won't hear any complaints from us about the R-Class' fit and finish. Past examples we've driven have felt drum-tight, though a little diesel and wind noise are inherent.

More Opinions:
ConsumerGuide: "six-footers have abundant 2nd-row headroom and knee space, plus adequate under seat foot space"
Cars.com: seats have "magisterial comfort and support, are wholly adjustable to suit one's physique, and remain appealing even after hours of driving"
ConsumerGuide: "cabin design is the expected blend of rich, textured plastics, soft-touch surfaces, and high-quality materials"
ConsumerGuide: "second- and 3rd-row seats fold easily to lay flush with the floor, providing a cargo hold that's nearly 8 feet long"
ConsumerGuide: "liftover is low for easy loading"
Cars.com: "optional second-row console contains additional cupholders, and bottle holders are located in each door pocket"
ConsumerGuide: diesel "intrusive during acceleration and noticeable at idle and in cruising"
Cars.com: "just a touch of driveline and road sound is evident"

9

2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class

Safety

The 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class hasn't been crash-tested by the feds, but private industry groups vouch for its high safety rating.

The 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class has better safety protection than it did even last year. A new POST-SAFE system disables electrical and fuel systems after an accident, while PRE-SAFE tightens seatbelts in advance of an accident.

All R-Class crossovers have anti-lock brakes; traction and stability control; four-wheel drive; dual front, side, and curtain airbags that cover the third seating row; and tire pressure monitors. A radar-based cruise control system, parking sensors, and a rearview camera are options.

The IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety) gives the R-Class "good" ratings for front and side impact protection; NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration) has not tested the R-Class.

More Opinions
Cars.com: "side curtain airbags protect occupants in all three rows of seats"
Edmunds: "steeply raked windshield affords excellent sight lines"
Cars.com: "a nest of headrests impairs the rearward view, which is otherwise OK and helped by ample mirrors"
Cars.com: "reflections are evident in the steep windshield, but they're not too distracting"

9

2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class

Features

There's no shortage of extra equipment for the 2010 Mercedes-Benz R-Class.

Mercedes simplifies some R-Class equipment and options, but caution's still the keyword as some features can only be had in expensive packages.

All R350 crossovers get standard vinyl upholstery; 19-inch wheels; wood trim; a leather-trimmed steering wheel; power front seats; dual-zone automatic climate control; power windows, mirrors, and locks; COMAND control for audio and entertainment systems; an AM/FM/DVD changer with SD memory slot and an auxiliary jack; and Bluetooth.

An iPod/MP3 interface, Sirius Satellite Radio with real-time traffic and data, and HD Radio are options, along with a rear-seat entertainment system. Other options include leather upholstery; a power liftgate; keyless entry and push-button start; a cargo tray; a seven-seat configuration; parking sensors; ventilated seats; a panoramic sunroof; a towing package; a heating steering wheel; the rear-seat entertainment system; and heated front seats.

More Opinions:
Edmunds: COMAND "lacks the control knob we've come to expect in premium vehicles"
Edmunds: "smorgasbord of identical-looking black buttons surrounding the COMAND screen"
Cars.com: "weather-band reception is included in the standard radio"
Car and Driver: "be careful when cruising the long list of optional temptations" Cars.com: "optional flat-screen monitors built into the back of the front head restraints can provide entertainment for rear passengers"

Continue Reading

The Car Connection Consumer Review

Rate and Review your car for The Car Connection! Tell us your own ratings for a vehicle you own. Rate your car on Performance, Safety, Features and more.
Write a Review
USED PRICE RANGE
$9,287 - $21,980
Browse Used Listings
in your area
8.2
Overall
Expert Rating
Rating breakdown on a scale of 1 to 10?
Styling 7.0
Performance 7.0
Comfort & Quality 9.0
Safety 9.0
Features 9.0
Fuel Economy N/A
Compare the 2010 Mercedes-Benz R Class against the competition
Compare All Cars
Looking for a different year of the Mercedes-Benz R Class?
Read reviews & get prices
Related Used Listings
Browse used listings in your area
See More Used