Find a Car

New Jersey, D.C., California Drivers Pay Big Bucks For Car Repair (Infographic)

Follow Richard

State-by-state ranking of car repair costs for 2012, from CarMD

State-by-state ranking of car repair costs for 2012, from CarMD

Enlarge Photo

No driver likes to see the "check engine" light pop on. Sometimes, it illuminates for a minor reason, like a loose gas cap. Other times, the problem is much more serious. Unless you have a diagnostic machine at your beck and call (or a tricked-out smartphone in your pocket), you won't know what's wrong until you take it in for service. 

Unfortunately, motorists in different states can have very different experiences at the auto shop, and they're likely to walk away with very different bills. The folks at CarMD recently looked at repair costs across the U.S. and confirmed once again that those costs are going up. However, they're not going up at the same rate, and in some cases, they're actually falling. 

To gather its data, CarMD analyzed 161,350 repairs carried out on vehicles from model years 1996 to 2012 during the 2012 calendar year. (Those repairs were logged into a database maintained by CarMD's network of Automotive Service Excellence-certified technicians.) The study was limited to repairs related to the vehicle's "check engine" system, meaning that many other problems -- belts, hoses, tires, bodywork -- were left out.

Here are the study's major takeaways:

  • In 2012, the average cost for auto repair in the U.S. was $367.84, up 10% from 2011.
  • Drivers in the Northeast were hit the hardest, with price jumps of 11.56%.
  • As we saw last year, drivers out West are often stuck with much higher repair costs than those living elsewhere. In 2012, however, Western residents saw only a 6.53% increase.
  • Folks in New Jersey saw the biggest jump in repair costs: labor shot up 20.7%, with parts rising 8.2%. According to CarMD, that's likely due to "more than double the number of trips to the repair shop spurred by Hurricane Sandy-related flood damage that either resulted in new repairs or uncovered unrepaired problems that had been put off for some time".
  • The most expensive areas for auto repair in 2012 were as follows:
    • 1. New Jersey: $392.99
    • 2. District of Columbia: $391.62
    • 3. California: $390.37
    • 4. North Carolina: $389.91
    • 5. Maryland: $387.78
  • At the other end of the scale, here are the five least-expensive states for repairs:
    • 47. Iowa: $314.77
    • 48. Delaware: $313.62
    • 49. South Dakota: $311.88
    • 50. West Virginia: $310.49
    • 51. Vermont: $269.72

Perhaps the best news that CarMD uncovered is that hybrid repair costs are on their way down. In fact, drivers in New Jersey paid less than anyone else to replace their hybrid batteries -- just $2,005.05, far below the high point of $4,409.94 recorded in Arizona. That's likely due to the increased presence of hybrid vehicles, parts, and mechanics to service them.

For more details, check out the CarMD infographic posted above.


Follow The Car Connection on FacebookTwitter and Google+.

Follow Us

Comments (2)
  1. OYou must be logged in to post your comment.f course, if you have Onstar, you can simply contact them and they will be glad to give you a free exact diagnosis. Note-I am a Buick GMC salesman!

  2. Sorry about that-did not realize it would carry the prompt. Should be "Of course" to start the comment.

Commenting is closed for old articles.
Try My Showroom
Save cars, write notes, and comparison shop with hi-res photos.
Add your first car
Take Us With You!

© 2015 The Car Connection. All Rights Reserved. The Car Connection is published by High Gear Media. Stock photography by izmo, Inc. Send us feedback.