Ford Escape Vs. Honda CR-VEnlarge Photo
It's easy to pick out the ways in which the new Escape excels--and the ways in which Honda's crossover carves out an even bigger niche for itself. It boils down to size and fun. If you're looking for the flexible, utility-driven safety specialist, take the CR-V. It's not rated as highly here, but in several critical categories, we've put it ahead of the Escape.
The most important scores for families--quality and comfort--are the ones in which the CR-V shines. It's a little smaller than the new Escape in some critical dimensions, but it delivers more usable interior space thanks to a more upright shape with more efficient packaging. The seats are more plushly upholstered, too--and the flip-fold mechanism that turns the second-row seat from passenger perch to cargo bench is the most clever touch in its class. By comparison, the Escape reads more like a tall station wagon, with the combination of a rather low dash but upright driving position feeling a little more carlike overall.
The CR-V also rules the safety rankings, earning not just a top five-star score from the federal government, and both models earn mostly 'good' scores from the IIHS. Both have a less-than-ideal performance in the new IIHS small overlap frontal test, with the Escape getting an especially low 'poor' rating. The Escape is also a four-star federal performer. It's not a complete smack--down though, as the Escape offers more advanced safety technology like parking sensors and active park assist.
For families hunting down a new commuting appliance, the CR-V works extremely well. That said, after a day's drive in the athletic, attractive new Escape, we'd give it the enthusiast nod, each and every time. Not only does it look the part of a hot hatchback--the CR-V's hunched-over back has nothing on Ford's rally-ready air intakes and rakish angles--the Escape's turbo thrust, ride and handling hold up to repeated thrashings. The electric power steering at least feels like it's in the game; the ride's very well damped, even taut; the 240-horsepower four's able to hit 60 mph in under 8 seconds, even with only a six-speed automatic running plays underfoot. (A pair of less powerful engines are available, too: a 2.5-liter four with 170 hp, and a turbo 1.6-liter four with 178 hp.)
Fuel economy ends up in Ford's corner: the CR-V's top EPA ratings hit 30 mpg, while the best Escape model is rated at 33 mpg highway.
For those times when running around off-road is part of the plan, the Escape can tow up to 3,500 pounds, and has optional all-wheel drive, just like the CR-V. Its cabin has much firmer seats with much thinner padding, which telegraphs a sportier feel without delivering discomfort. Its back seats fold forward too, though not with the final flourish of fold-forward fancy that Honda's mustered in the CR-V.
As for features, the Escape triumphs, though Honda's made good progress. The CR-V now has standard Bluetooth, and streaming audio and mobile connectivity are reality. The Escape feels in a class above, if you shop by feature lists, with options for leather, a panoramic sunroof, MyFord Touch's voice-command controls, even a hands-free tailgate that opens or closes with the wave of a foot.
In the end, it's a decision between brand-new and carefully updated crossovers. The Escape's a wholly different vehicle that the faux-truck that was not so long ago discontinued. The CR-V on the other hand has changed in no-nonsense, evolutionary ways, keeping it at the top of the class for the mission it has in mind. Our advice: If you're so busy you barely have time to think of the driving itself, get the CR-V; but if you want a little fun sprinkled in, the Escape stays true to its name.
|2014 Ford Escape||2014 Honda CR-V|
|With authentically athletic looks and performance balancing out good passenger space, cargo versatility, and loads of high-tech features, the 2014 Ford Escape is attractive to a wide range of buyers.||The 2014 Honda CR-V isn't exactly sprightly, but it nails efficiency on a few levels and finally brings more features to the family-wagon fight.|
|Read moreThe Escape doesn't bother nodding to the past; it forgets about the old SUV look and dashes for a more dynamic look.||Read moreSimplicity rules inside, while on the outside some might find the 2014 Honda CR-V a little too nondescript.|
|Read moreThe Escape is one of the best-handling crossovers in its class, and the 240-hp turbo four helps make the most of it.||Read moreThe 2014 Honda CR-V is confident and smooth, even though excitement is sorely lacking.|
|Read moreThe Escape is small -- compared to other compact crossovers even -- but it makes good use of the space and has great front seats.||Read moreYou'll find loads of interior space and very smart seat-folding; yet materials and trims might be a disappointment to some.|
|Read moreGood safety ratings and plenty of safety features -- including a new standard rearview camera system -- makes the 2014 Escape a great family pick.||Read moreThe 2014 Honda CR-V gets mostly top ratings from both major U.S. safety agencies, but the IIHS small overlap test leaves room for improvement.|
|Read moreLeather upholstery, a panoramic sunroof, and Sony sound boost the Escape past other bargain crossovers -- but the price goes up accordingly.||Read moreAvailable infotainment systems are on par with those found elsewhere--although you still need to move to the top EX-L to get some extras, like satellite radio.|
|Read moreSome models of the 2014 Ford Escape will top 30 mpg on the highway.||Read moreMileage ratings for the 2014 Honda CR-V are among the highest mileage in its class, but tall gear ratios don't always translate that to real-world driving.|
|from $23,100||from $22,945|
|from $21,772||from $21,553|
|Fuel Economy - Combined City and Highway|
|Front Leg Room (in)|
|Second Leg Room (in)|
Read Full Specs
Read Full Specs