2016 Mazda CX-9 vs. 2017 Toyota Highlander: Compare Cars

October 17, 2016
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo

While shopping for a three-row, seven-seat crossover or SUV, you're likely to include one of the best-sellers in that group: the Toyota Highlander. But it's also worth considering another model offering a relatively sporty driving experience: the Mazda CX-9.

We like them both, but for very different reasons. The Mazda excels for its fun-to-drive nature and its detail-oriented interior, but it's the Highlander that ultimately makes feels like the better family-oriented vehicle thanks to its more flexible interior. We've rated the Highlander a 7.2 out of 10 using our new scale, but we're still waiting to grade the CX-9 using the same metrics. (Read more about how we rate cars.)

MORE: Read our reviews of the 2016 Mazda CX-9 and the 2017 Toyota Highlander

How do the two models stack up? Both are likely to be safe and reliable, but they have very different personalities. The CX-9 was redesigned for 2016 from the ground up, and while it kind of looks like a revamped version of its dated predecessor, all the two really share is a badge and a general outlook on life. 

2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo

Under its hood, the CX-9 utilizes a downsized, turbocharged inline-4 that replaces a heavier V-6. With up to 250 horsepower and 310 pound-feet of torque coming on boost early, the CX-9 has strong acceleration subdued behind lots of sound deadening and thick glass. Regardless of trim level, the CX-9 features a buttoned-down suspension and the most communicative steering we've ever seen in a three-row crossover.

The Highlander takes a more conventional approach, but that's by no means a bad thing. Most 2017 Highlander models are powered by a revised, direct-injected 3.5-liter V-6, which produces 295 hp, up 25 horses this year. These models also get a new 8-speed automatic transmission that has an expanded torque-converter lockup range and what Toyota describes as a more direct driving feel.This new powertrain improves both pep and fuel economy. The V-6 tops out at 21 mpg city, 27 highway.

The base Highlander utilizes a 2.7-liter 4-cylinder that, frankly, is unlikely to return better real-world fuel economy since it's a little low on power for this large vehicle. There's also a Highlander Hybrid that delivers 306 net hp thanks to a supplemental electric motor, and it allows for impressive 30/28 mpg figures. That said, the Highlander Hybrid's price tag puts it in dedicated luxury territory. 

2016 Mazda CX-9

2016 Mazda CX-9

Enlarge Photo
2016 Mazda CX-9

2016 Mazda CX-9

Enlarge Photo
2016 Mazda CX-9

2016 Mazda CX-9

Enlarge Photo
2016 Mazda CX-9

2016 Mazda CX-9

Enlarge Photo

On the road, the CX-9 is certainly the more enjoyable to drive, its suspension straddling the line between sporty and comfortable in ways we typically only see from high-end crossovers from the likes of Porsche and Audi. Its steering is direct and remarkably communicative, two accolades we don't levy on crossovers very often. That said, there's no real reason to fault the Highlander's road manners. Its suspension is compliant and comfortable, smothering out even the roughest of bumps with ease, albeit without the Mazda's verve.

But, let's be honest here, you're probably buying a three-row crossover for its passenger-hauling capability. To that end, the Highlander delivers terrific first and second row room and above average accommodations out back. Its second row moves out the way easily for access to the third row which folds flat when called upon for more passengers. And there's good space behind its third row when it's up. By contrast, the Mazda feels tighter in every seat, even though it's not. But if more than four passengers is relatively rare in your household, you'll be perfectly fine with the CX-9.

Both models offer good infotainment systems, although we ding the CX-9 for relying on a control knob rather than a proper touchscreen. The Highlander's system is less flashy, but it's very functional and it works really well. 

Safety sells when it comes to family-oriented crossovers and both of these vehicles are at the top of their game. The Highlander receives the best available marks from the IIHS and, crucially, it comes standard for 2017 with automatic emergency braking that can detect pedestrians, as well as lane departure warning, adaptive cruise control, and automatic high beam headlamps. It receives a surprising four stars for frontal collision from the NHTSA, but it's still rated at five stars overall. 

The CX-9 hasn't yet been tested by either agency, and while new safety technology is fitted on more expensive models, the features are unavailable on the base Sport model. Mid-range versions get blind-spot monitors, while the top trims add a bundle of safety technology that includes adaptive cruise control (good for operating at up to 90 mph), lane-keep assist, lane-departure warnings, and forward-collision warnings with automatic emergency braking. 

Which one is better for you? If you're a fan of sporty driving, the CX-9 channels enough of its inner Miata to be entertaining. But the Highlander's broader lineup may make it a better fit for you. 

___________________________________________

Follow The Car Connection on Facebook and Twitter

Summary

7.8
Expert Rating
The 2016 Mazda CX-9 has sharp handling and sleek looks, but falls a bit shy in features and third-row space.
7.0
Expert Rating
The Toyota Highlander gets a stronger, more responsive powertrain for 2017, but the main strengths are the ride quality, the cabin refinement, and the space for eight.

Styling

8.0
Expert Rating
Taut lines and its best interior yet give the Mazda CX-9 great presence and elegance.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
The Highlander's interior has the look and feel of a modern crossover, while the exterior reads more as a truck.
Read More

Performance

8.0
Expert Rating
The CX-9's enlightened body and powertrain give it great road manners.
Read More
5.0
Expert Rating
A smooth ride and a strong V-6 are the highlights, but the standard 4-cylinder is weak and the handling is uninspired.
Read More

Comfort & Quality

8.0
Expert Rating
The CX-9 needs more comfortable seats, but three-row space is par for the class, or better.
Read More
8.0
Expert Rating
The Highlander's cabin features comfortable seats, room for eight, quality finishes, and lots of cargo space.
Read More

Safety

7.0
Expert Rating
The new CX-9 adds a raft of cutting-edge safety features, but skips others and hasn't been crash-tested yet.
Read More
9.0
Expert Rating
Top crash scores and a host of standard safety features give families peace of mind.
Read More

Features

8.0
Expert Rating
Mazda fits some high-end gear to the CX-9, but top safety features only come on expensive models, and the infotainment system is lacking.
Read More
8.0
Expert Rating
Toyota expands Hybrid availability and adds a sportier SE model to its already extensive lineup.
Read More

Fuel Economy

6.0
Expert Rating
Mazda meets a high standard for crossover-SUV gas mileage.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
Highlander Hybrid fuel economy is great by the ratings, but not in the real world; V-6 efficiency improves this year.
Read More

MSRP

from $31,520
from $30,630

Invoice

from $29,833
from $27,965

Fuel Economy - Combined City and Highway

25
22

Engine

Intercooled Turbo Regular Unleaded I-4, 2.5 L
Regular Unleaded I-4, 2.7 L

Drivetrain

Front Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Front Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Compare Free Dealer Price Quote
With competitive price quotes from multiple dealers, you will be prepared when you meet your local car dealer. Please tell us how to contact you so that dealers can compete for your business!
Search Dealers by ZIP Code
Update ZIP Code
2016 Mazda CX-9
2017 Toyota Highlander
Looking for dealers in your area...
Powered By
We are committed to your privacy. By submitting this form you agree the phone number you provided may be used to contact you (including text, autodialed or pre-recorded calls). Consent is not a condition of purchase.
2018
The Car Connection
See the nominees and vote »
2018
The Car Connection
 
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
Related Head to Head
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.