2017 Honda Pilot vs. 2017 Toyota Highlander: Compare Cars

December 5, 2016

If you recoil at the prospect of driving a minivan, the roomiest seven- and eight-passenger crossovers are pretty good substitutes. And if your escape from sliding doors brought you to either the Honda Pilot or the Toyota Highlander, you're on the right path.

But which fits your family better? Read on carefully, as it comes down to a few subtle yet important points. Both of these models are among the best three-row crossover SUVs—affordable yet comfortable, safe, and well-equipped. The Pilot, which was new for 2016, is far more appealing to the eye, with softer styling that suits its road-going mission. The Highlander has received an update for 2017 that adds a more macho, but more awkward, front end.

MORE: Read our reviews of the 2017 Honda Pilot and the 2017 Toyota Highlander

We've rated the Highlander a 7.2 out of 10, but the Pilot comes out on top by a few ticks. (Read more about how we rate cars.)

2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Highlander

2017 Toyota Highlander

Enlarge Photo

The Highlander scores well for its variety of powertrains. A base 4-cylinder earns fair economy (22 mpg combined); it's topped by a fairly expensive Hybrid model that's rated at up to 29 mpg combined by the EPA. The strong 295-horsepower V-6 is best for towing or carrying a full load of passengers often, and it's actually more efficient than the strained 4-cylinder.

The Pilot comes with a 280-hp V-6 in base versions; the engine is coupled to either a 6- or a 9-speed automatic, with a smart all-wheel-drive system that can shift power front to back, and between the rear wheels. With either, you probably only need AWD if you live in a place where rough weather lasts for more than a month each year. Honda's best fuel-economy number is 23 mpg combined for a pricey front-drive Touring model.

Over a couple of generations, both the Pilot and the Highlander have proven themselves worthy for family-utility duty—they're modern station wagons with cavernous interiors. Yet if there's one distinct thing that separates the Pilot from the Highlander, it's the Honda's driving feel. It has a fairly firm, well-damped ride and light but responsive steering.

2016 Honda Pilot

2016 Honda Pilot

Enlarge Photo
2016 Honda Pilot

2016 Honda Pilot

Enlarge Photo
2016 Honda Pilot

2016 Honda Pilot

Enlarge Photo

You'll enjoy driving the Pilot, and while the Highlander is pleasant, it still suffers from numb steering and a harsher ride in heavier versions. The Honda, across the lineup, has better ride control; it's supple and absorbent.

In safety, the Pilot has earned a Top Safety Pick+ from the IIHS. The Highlander, with its combination of "Good" safety ratings in all categories, is a Top Safety Pick+ selection as well. Both also get 5-star government ratings. Visibility has vastly improved in the Pilot, with its slimmer roof pillars and its standard wide-angle rearview camera, while the Highlander gets more standard safety equipment.

Both of these models are tall and spacious, as well as easy to load and get into and out of (despite the lack of sliding doors). The Pilot's caught up to the Highlander in terms of second-row seating, with an option for captain's chairs, a one-touch sliding mechanism and a lower step-in height. The Pilot's third-row seat isn't so easy for adults to access, but once in, they fit—something that's less true with the Toyota.

Both interiors brim with useful cubbies and bins, and convenience and luxury features abound. Both can be fitted with a power tailgate, DVD entertainment systems, Bluetooth, navigation, and other luxury features. If you're on a budget, Toyota's edge has disappeared, now that both carry similar base prices and equipment, including a USB port, Bluetooth audio streaming, and Bluetooth hands-free calling connectivity.

When we tally up our numeric ratings, it's the Pilot that comes out on top. It's an energetic performer, and a good-looking one, with slightly better interior space and comfort. If you're looking for the ultimate in fuel economy, the Highlander gets the nod for its Hybrid, and it also comes standard with more safety features.

Summary

7.0
Expert Rating
The Toyota Highlander gets a stronger, more responsive powertrain for 2017, but the main strengths are the ride quality, the cabin refinement, and the space for eight.
7.5
Expert Rating
The 2017 Honda Pilot is a capable, refined crossover SUV with all the goodness of a minivan, save for the sliding doors.

Styling

6.0
Expert Rating
The Highlander's interior has the look and feel of a modern crossover, while the exterior reads more as a truck.
Read More
7.0
Expert Rating
A trim, sedately styled body and interior put the Honda Pilot right in the crossover mainstream.
Read More

Performance

5.0
Expert Rating
A smooth ride and a strong V-6 are the highlights, but the standard 4-cylinder is weak and the handling is uninspired.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
The Pilot's amiable road manners put ride comfort ahead of sharp steering and quick shifts.
Read More

Comfort & Quality

8.0
Expert Rating
The Highlander's cabin features comfortable seats, room for eight, quality finishes, and lots of cargo space.
Read More
9.0
Expert Rating
The Pilot has one of the most useful interiors among crossovers; even adults can fit in its third-row seat.
Read More

Safety

9.0
Expert Rating
Top crash scores and a host of standard safety features give families peace of mind.
Read More
9.0
Expert Rating
The Pilot's very good crash-test scores are accompanied by lots of leading safety features.
Read More

Features

8.0
Expert Rating
Toyota expands Hybrid availability and adds a sportier SE model to its already extensive lineup.
Read More
8.0
Expert Rating
The Pilot adds CarPlay and Android Auto to its ample standard features list this year.
Read More

Fuel Economy

6.0
Expert Rating
Highlander Hybrid fuel economy is great by the ratings, but not in the real world; V-6 efficiency improves this year.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
The Pilot's gas mileage is average, but we're seeing economy lower than official ratings.
Read More

MSRP

from N/A
from $30,745

Invoice

from N/A
from $28,117

Fuel Economy - Combined City and Highway

22
22

Engine

Regular Unleaded V-6, 3.5 L
Regular Unleaded V-6, 3.5 L

Drivetrain

All Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Front Wheel Drive Read Full Specs
Compare Free Dealer Price Quote
With competitive price quotes from multiple dealers, you will be prepared when you meet your local car dealer. Please tell us how to contact you so that dealers can compete for your business!
Search Dealers by ZIP Code
Update ZIP Code
2017 Toyota Highlander
2017 Honda Pilot
Looking for dealers in your area...
Powered By
We are committed to your privacy. By submitting this form you agree the phone number you provided may be used to contact you (including text, autodialed or pre-recorded calls). Consent is not a condition of purchase.
2017
The Car Connection
See the winners »
2017
The Car Connection
 
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
Related Head to Head
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.