2017 Nissan Frontier vs. 2017 Toyota Tacoma: Compare Trucks

October 17, 2016
2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

Enlarge Photo

Just a couple of years ago, mid-size pickup buyers would have been stuck with these two choices: The Nissan Frontier and the Toyota Tacoma. 

Flash forward to today, however, and there are some compelling new entries on the market: The Chevrolet Colorado, the GMC Canyon, and the Honda Ridgeline. But that's not to say that the old nameplates have stood pat over the last few years. Well, one of them has. Let's get to that in a minute. (Read more about how we rate cars.)

MORE: Read our reviews of the 2017 Nissan Frontier and the 2017 Toyota Tacoma

2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

Enlarge Photo
2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

2017 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

Enlarge Photo

That said, we're fairly confident that the Tacoma will outpace the Frontier—unless Nissan has a really big trick up its sleeve. The Tacoma was redesigned for 2016, gaining a new look, a new engine, a new transmission, a lot of technology upgrades... you get the idea. The Frontier, on the other hand, has only been lightly updated since its 2005 model year redesign. That's more than a decade on the market.

The Tacoma gained a new 3.5-liter direct-injection V-6 that makes 278 horsepower and 265 pound-feet of torque mated to 6-speed manual or automatic transmissions. There’s still a base 4-cylinder version of the Tacoma, with a 2.7-liter inline-4 making 159 hp and 180 lb-ft of torque paired to automatic or manual 5-speed transmissions. 

By contrast, the Frontier's base engine is rated at just 152 hp, but it feels like even less. Most buyers opt for the robust 4.0-liter V-6 with its 261 horsepower and 281 lb-ft of torque. The Frontier is downright quick, but it's also downright thirsty. While the V-6, automatic, 4x4 Tacoma is rated by the EPA at 18 mpg city, 23 highway, 20 combined, the Frontier is just 15/21/17. That's a difference worth noting.

In real-world use, the Tacoma benefits from some major suspension revisions last year that help it ride especially well for a mid-size pickup. In this regard, the Frontier has aged fairly well; its steering is accurate and its suspension is reasonably well-controlled.

However, the differences begin to mount again when you look at the way the two trucks are outfitted. The Frontier's interior is from a different decade—literally. In both, you'll find a legs-out driving position that's rather un-truck-like, a relic of their high ground clearance and relatively low-roof designs. The General Motors and Honda competitors deliver a more comfortable driving position overall. In terms of infotainment, it's not even a comparison. The Frontier's audio systems feel dated, even at the upper end of the lineup. The Tacoma offers Toyota's solid Entune infotainment, which is easy to use and features a nice, clear screen. 

2016 Nissan Frontier

2016 Nissan Frontier

Enlarge Photo
2016 Nissan Frontier

2016 Nissan Frontier

Enlarge Photo
2016 Nissan Frontier

2016 Nissan Frontier

Enlarge Photo

There's a lot more breadth to the Tacoma lineup, too. Anchoring the bottom end of the lineup is the value-oriented SR, while the SR5 is designed to be the high-volume model. But off-roaders will appreciate the TRD Off Road and new TRD Pro packages that deliver the highest degree of four-wheeling capability found in a mid-size pickup. The Frontier's lineup is similar, starting off with workaday S and SV trim levels. The PRO-4X is the most hardcore off-roader of the pack, with its Bilstein suspension and locking rear differential, but it doesn't match both TRD models' crawl control, advanced traction control systems, and outright ground clearance. 

So where does the Frontier score? Its age is an asset if you're a value shopper. While it's not priced that much less than the Tacoma, strong demand for the Toyota means that discounts are relatively minor. The Frontier should have money on its hood before you even walk into the showroom.

On the safety front, we don't really have a complete picture for either truck as we're still awaiting some crash test data (which typically comes slowly for pickups). Neither offers any sort of active collision avoidance tech, however, which is something we hope to see on both models soon.

What'll be the right truck for you? 

___________________________________________

Follow The Car Connection on Facebook and Twitter.


Summary

4.8
Expert Rating
Thoroughly outpointed by its rivals, the 2017 Nissan Frontier is nonetheless worth a look if you value its nimble feel and its surprisingly good value.
6.4
Expert Rating
A new TRD Pro package further cements the 2017 Toyota Tacoma's reputation as an off-road leader.

Styling

4.0
Expert Rating
Having been on the market for a decade, the Frontier is a little too familiar now.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
The Tacoma's blunt snout seems at odds with its rather ordinary side profile, but its interior looks and feels great for the class.
Read More

Performance

5.0
Expert Rating
With its big tires, the PRO-4X is the best-riding Frontier—and it's an impressive off-roader.
Read More
7.0
Expert Rating
A strong V-6 and willing 6-speed transmissions combine with above average off road ability to make the Tacoma even better at what it has always done well.
Read More

Comfort & Quality

4.0
Expert Rating
Only high-end models offer a height-adjustable driver's seat and even crew cabs are tight in the rear.
Read More
6.0
Expert Rating
A low roof and a high floor combine to give the Tacoma an awkward driving position, but its interior is otherwise above average.
Read More

Safety

We don't have all the crash test data yet for the Frontier, but what's there has been positive.
Read More
Not all crash tests are in, but the 2017 Tacoma has performed well in tests so far.
Read More

Features

6.0
Expert Rating
Frontier isn't available with as many options as its rivals, but it offers good value and trim levels are well-packaged.
Read More
8.0
Expert Rating
Although it doesn't offer a diesel or an ultra high-luxe version, the Tacoma is still available with a dizzying array of features.
Read More

Fuel Economy

5.0
Expert Rating
The Frontier's fuel economy has more in common with full-size trucks than mid-sizers.
Read More
5.0
Expert Rating
The Tacoma comes in dead average in the mid-size truck segment for its fuel efficiency.
Read More

MSRP

from $18,390
from $24,320

Invoice

from $17,769
from $22,800

Fuel Economy - Combined City and Highway

21
21

Front Leg Room (in)

42.4
42.9

Second Leg Room (in)

Compare Free Dealer Price Quote
With competitive price quotes from multiple dealers, you will be prepared when you meet your local car dealer. Please tell us how to contact you so that dealers can compete for your business!
Search Dealers by ZIP Code
Update ZIP Code
2017 Nissan Frontier
2017 Toyota Tacoma
Looking for dealers in your area...
Powered By
We are committed to your privacy. By submitting this form you agree the phone number you provided may be used to contact you (including text, autodialed or pre-recorded calls). Consent is not a condition of purchase.
2017
The Car Connection
See the winners »
2017
The Car Connection
 
Ratings and Reviews
Rate and review your car for The Car Connection
Review your car
Related Head to Head
The Car Connection Daily Headlines
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.
Thank you! Please check your email for confirmation.