The 2010 Suzuki SX4 Sportback is one of that latter group. Although it comes up short in a few respects—like fuel economy ratings—it's quite simply a little more fun to drive than most other small hatches.
To arrive at the SX4 Sportback, Suzuki finally took the five-door hatchback body of its SX4 Crossover and mated it to the front-wheel drive powertrain and lower sport suspension of its SX4 Sport sedan. The automaker had been stubbornly offering the five-door only with the softer-riding Outback-like package, but hot-hatch fans cried foul and got their way.
The verdict? The SX4 is a blast to drive—especially if your commute includes curvy country lanes, or for that matter even just some clogged traffic arteries where maneuverability helps.
Yank the steering wheel abruptly to the side and the SX4 always responds crisply…to a degree. Push it beyond moderately hard, and the front end changes demeanor altogether allowing lots more body roll. We wish Suzuki had chosen to offer some stout anti-roll bars to help keep that in check, but until the automaker offers more power it's plenty of suspension for the engine, and surprisingly fun on tightly curved canyon roads in second and third gear.
Also, the 150-horsepower, 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine in the SX4 feels eager at city speeds, revving energetically. Add a nice smooth clutch takeup and a neat, clear shift linkage for the standard six-speed manual (a CVT with paddle-shifters and six simulated gears is optional) and it's entertaining.
But there are some less desirable qualities to the powertrain. The engine can feel downright lifeless below 2,000 in any of the upper gears if you're caught off guard, but it comes alive again by the time you reach the '3' on the tach. It gets boomy above 4500, so you learn to keep it in the sweet spot in the middle. Other than that, the throws of the shifter are a little long, and the aggressive tip-in for the gas pedal that makes it feel so perky at first disappoints in the end, seemingly giving 3/4 throttle at 1/4 of pedal travel.
To get the rest of the downside out of the way, the SX4 doesn't do highway very well, and even though it does hold the road surely and track very well at 70 mph and beyond, there's an ever-present fore-aft choppiness that could add to fatigue on longer rides. There was also a fair bit of road noise over coarse surfaces in our sport-suspension-equipped SportBack (to be fair, not any more than in a Honda Fit), but when the road wasn't so coarse, we noticed the almost ever-present whine from sixth gear on our test car (not fifth).
At the pump, you'll probably be able to do a lot better than the SX4's fuel economy ratings of 23 mpg city / 30 highway, indicate. Over about 230 miles in a week—a mix of weekday city errands and a longer leisurely weekend drive on two-laners—we averaged 29 mpg in the SX4. But we noticed that mileage plummeted whenever we reached Interstate speeds.