Find a Car

Economics 101: How Driving Into Manhattan Costs $160

Follow John

Manhattan traffic, by Flickr ruser JamesH2008

Manhattan traffic, by Flickr ruser JamesH2008

Enlarge Photo

It's Friday, which is our day for more esoteric items. Today's offering: A dense economics blog post, which covers an even more frighteningly complex model for assessing the costs of traffic in New York City.

The punch line: If you drive your car into Manhattan, adding to the traffic there causes thousands of little delays for all the other vehicles in the city. And the total value of those delays is $160.

Reuters blogger, commentator, and economist Felix Salmon cites that example from "Charles Komanoff’s absolutely astonishing Balanced Tranportation Analyzer — a 3.5 MB Excel spreadsheet [that]is the product of many years of research and analysis into the question of New York City traffic."

On weekdays, says Komanoff, a car driven into the most congested area of Manhattan--south of 60th Street--causes delays for every other vehicle that total 3.26 hours. If, he calculates, an average vehicle has 1.97 people in it, the average value of an hour of saved vehicle time is $48.89. Multiply 3.26 hours by $48.89/hour, and there's your $160.

Drivers don't pay that directly, of course. That's the cost imposed on everyone else by the presence of their vehicle. In economic theory, that's known as an "externality"--a cost incurred somewhere else than by the person who causes it. Air pollution, for example, is an externality:  Minus carbon taxes or cap-and-trade schemes, the emitters don't pay the costs of fouling the air. The rest of us do.

Where does all this lead? Komanoff lets users model different costs for entering Manhattan, and the idea of congestion pricing--imposing a toll to enter a crowded center-city area, as is now done in London and Stockholm--is never too far away from his analysis.

The basic rules of economic theory would indicate that a scarce resource (road space in Manhattan) should cost more than an abundant resource. And if the costs of entering Manhattan rose, it would get less congested--saving time and money for all.

But try telling that to the politicians. Or, for that matter, the drivers.

[Reuters Blogs; Manhattan traffic photo by Flickr user JamesH2008]

Posted in:
Follow Us


Have an opinion?

  • Posting indicates you have read this site's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • Notify me when there are more comments
Comment (1)
  1. Of course, rather than getting the politicians involved at all, the obvious solution is to privatise the roads, allowing each road owner to price the use of their road in the best way they can - pretty soon, they will find the right price to maximise the number of cars passing over their road, and therefore their profit.
    Putting a standard congestion tax on all the busy roads is a blunt instrument. The effect of classing some roads as congestion-taxable and others as not, will be to make the roads just outside the 'congestion-zone' incredibly busy, as people try to skirt the area as closely as possible.
    Post Reply
    Bad stuff?


Have an opinion? Join the conversation!

Try My Showroom
Save cars, write notes, and comparison shop with hi-res photos.
Add your first car
Take Us With You!

© 2015 The Car Connection. All Rights Reserved. The Car Connection is published by High Gear Media. Stock photography by izmo, Inc. Send us feedback.