2009 Saturn VUE Quality Review

March 16, 2009

COMFORT AND QUALITY | 7 out of 10

Expert Quotes:

clever storage solutions in the rear cargo area
Automobile Magazine

wind noise is low even in crosswinds
ConsumerGuide

Seats were supportive and straddled the line between cushy and firm
Cars.com

Interior silence of the recently redesigned Saturn Vue is deafening and an obvious improvement over earlier models. The material qualities of 2009 Vue’s cabin are also a marked improvement.

The Saturn Vue does a wonderful job of suppressing external noise. According to ConsumerGuide, "wind noise is low even in crosswinds," and Cars.com adds "there's almost no engine noise and very little wind or road noise on even the most abrasive highway lanes."

When evaluating the seats in the Saturn Vue, a few complaints arise. Reviewers at Automobile Magazine are quick to point out that "the front seat bottoms are too low and too short," though The Detroit News mentions "plenty of leg room in the front (40.7 inches) and the second row (36.9 inches)." Consumer Guide agrees that there is "good headroom and legroom" up front, but they again note that the "short seat bottoms lack long-distance thigh support." As for the rear seats, Consumer Guide reports that they offer "excellent headroom" and a "reclining seatback," though once more with "short seat bottoms, and too-firm cushioning." According to Edmunds, the 2009 Saturn Vue "is a five-passenger compact SUV," and many reviews read by TheCarConnection.com decry the lack of an available third-row seat.

Regarding interior storage space, Car and Driver lays out hard numbers: "luggage space comes in at 29 cubic feet behind the second row and 54 cubic feet with the second row folded, which is noticeably less than the 36 and 73 cubic feet in the RAV4." At Automobile Magazine, reviewers note that "the glove box is huge and there are some clever storage solutions in the rear cargo area." However, ConsumerGuide marks down the Saturn Vue because its "in-cabin storage is meager." Although the 2009 Saturn Vue isn't a huge car, it does offer average storage space and usability. Reviewers at The Detroit News love all "the small storage containers, including a drawer under the passenger's front seat," which "give the space purpose instead of becoming a black hole for garage remotes." ConsumerGuide reports that there is "good space behind the 2nd row," and it "becomes plentiful with the rear seatbacks folded."

Cars.com reviewers contend that the materials used inside the 2009 Saturn Vue not only "best other domestics, like the Ford Escape, it's also superior to top imports like the Toyota RAV4, Hyundai Santa Fe and Honda CR-V." Edmunds notes "brushed-aluminum accents on the steering wheel, door panels, parking brake and shift knob further the upscale treatment." Kelley Blue Book offers particularly high praise, declaring, "especially when outfitted with leather, the Saturn Vue offers the richest passenger cabin in the category." ConsumerGuide agrees, stating that the new interior is "a vast upgrade over the previous-generation Vue" and claiming "materials quality and assembly of models tested are arguably the best in the compact-SUV class."

Conclusion

While cargo room could be more plentiful, the 2009 Saturn Vue is a class leader when it comes to a silent, quality-built cabin.

COMFORT AND QUALITY | 7 out of 10Expert Quotes:clever storage solutions in the rear cargo areaAutomobile Magazinewind noise is low even in crosswindsConsumerGuideSeats were supportive and straddled the line between cushy and firmCars.com Interior silence of the recently redesigned Saturn Vue is deafening and an obvious improvement over earlier models. The material qualities of 2009 Vue’s cabin are also a marked improvement. The Saturn Vue does a wonderful job of suppressing external noise. According to ConsumerGuide, "wind noise is low even in crosswinds," and Cars.com adds "there's almost no engine noise and very little wind or road noise on even the most abrasive highway lanes." When evaluating the seats in the Saturn Vue, a few complaints arise. Reviewers at Automobile Magazine are quick to point out that "the front seat bottoms are too low and too short," though The Detroit News mentions "plenty of leg room in the front (40.7 inches) and the second row (36.9 inches)." Consumer Guide agrees that there is "good headroom and legroom" up front, but they again note that the "short seat bottoms lack long-distance thigh support." As for the rear seats, Consumer Guide reports that they offer "excellent headroom" and a "reclining seatback," though once more with "short seat bottoms, and too-firm cushioning." According to Edmunds, the 2009 Saturn Vue "is a five-passenger compact SUV," and many reviews read by TheCarConnection.com decry the lack of an available third-row seat. Regarding interior storage space, Car and Driver lays out hard numbers: "luggage space comes in at 29 cubic feet behind the second row and 54 cubic feet with the second row folded, which is noticeably less than the 36 and 73 cubic feet in the RAV4." At Automobile Magazine, reviewers note that "the glove box is huge and there are some clever storage solutions in the rear cargo area." However, ConsumerGuide marks down the Saturn Vue because its "in-cabin storage is meager." Although the 2009 Saturn Vue isn't a huge car, it does offer average storage space and usability. Reviewers at The Detroit News love all "the small storage containers, including a drawer under the passenger's front seat," which "give the space purpose instead of becoming a black hole for garage remotes." ConsumerGuide reports that there is "good space behind the 2nd row," and it "becomes plentiful with the rear seatbacks folded." Cars.com reviewers contend that the materials used inside the 2009 Saturn Vue not only "best other domestics, like the Ford Escape, it's also superior to top imports like the Toyota RAV4, Hyundai Santa Fe and Honda CR-V." Edmunds notes "brushed-aluminum accents on the steering wheel, door panels, parking brake and shift knob further the upscale treatment." Kelley Blue Book offers particularly high praise, declaring, "especially when outfitted with leather, the Saturn Vue offers the richest passenger cabin in the category." ConsumerGuide agrees, stating that the new interior is "a vast upgrade over the previous-generation Vue" and claiming "materials quality and assembly of models tested are arguably the best in the compact-SUV class." ConclusionWhile cargo room could be more plentiful, the 2009 Saturn Vue is a class leader when it comes to a silent, quality-built cabin. 2009 SATURN VUE STYLING | [8 out of 10] The Detroit News: "crossover with character" ConsumerGuide: "Everything is well laid out and easy to see" Cars.com: "One of the most aggressively styled SUVs on the road" Most reviews read by TheCarConnection.com show the styling of the 2009 ...

Read More of this Review:

  1. styling
  2. performance
  3. quality
  4. safety
  5. features

Other Choices:

The 2009 Saturn Vue’s primary rival is perhaps the Honda CR-V, a vehicle that was recently redesigned and boasts a roomy interior and smooth ride. But the CR-V comes with only a peppy and efficient four-cylinder engine, and it's quite a bit lighter than the Vue. The comparably priced Toyota RAV4 is about the same size as the Vue on the outside, but it has seating for seven and a third-row seat, along with a more efficient four-cylinder engine and a more powerful V-6. The Subaru Forester is another alternative; compared to the Vue, the Forester drives more like a sporty small car, with crisp handling and good performance from its flat-four engine, plus standard all-wheel drive. The Ford Escape, despite a recent reskin, looks dated but is still very competitive, with a space-efficient design. The Vue's fuel economy is not as good as that of either the Ford Escape or Toyota RAV4 when equipped with their optional V-6 engines.

Next Steps:

Get a free price quote

for the 2009 Saturn VUE from a dealer near you

Check Insurance Rates

for the 2009 Saturn VUE

Check Financing Rates

for the 2009 Saturn VUE

Check Local Classifieds

for a 2009 Saturn VUE near you

See the Saturn VUE in Other Years:

2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002

Comments (1 total)

  1. By Paulie #1, Posted: 4/8/2009

    Less cargo space and worse fuel efficiency

    Comparing my 2004 Saturn VUE AWD, the 2009 model is 864 lbs heavier, has 8 cu ft less max cargo capacity, as is less fuel efficient. So why would I want to trade up just to get nicer interior?

Post a comment

Post anonymously, or
(Required)
(Required - will not be published, sold or shared)
(Optional - your 'posted by' name will link to the URL)

Remember Me?

I have read TheCarConnection.com's privacy policy