2009 BMW 1-Series vs. Its Competition

Meta Rating 8 out of 10

Browse Used Listings
What’s this?

What’s this? X

Our expert editors build comparisons like this one to make it easy for you to understand the small handful of cars you should compare to whatever car you are already looking at. You get general thoughts on each car you should consider plus an easy way to compare basic information for yourself.

Trevor Wild

Author

N/ALEADERBOARD RANK
1311ARTICLES CONTRIBUTED
0COMMENTS POSTED

May 26, 2009

Beyond the more expensive 3-Series, there aren't many direct model-per-model competitors to the 1-Series.

In terms of body styles (2+2 coupe and convertible), the Ford Mustang GT comes closest, but because of its domestic roots, we doubt there will be much cross-shopping between these two.

A more realistic competitor is the V-6-powered Infiniti G37 Coupe, although the G37 is not offered as a convertible.

Those looking for a track-worthy car that has head-turning potential and a truly unique driving experience might consider the RX8, though this little Mazda isn’t that practical or fuel-efficient.

Finally, a 135i Coupe roughly aligns in price with a 328i Coupe—it’s worth considering whether you'd trade a more comfortable driving experience and better styling overall for less power.

2009 BMW 1-Series Browse Used Listings	2009 Mazda RX-8 Browse Used Listings	2008 BMW 3-Series Browse Used Listings	2008 Infiniti G37 Coupe Browse Used Listings
Quick Specs
Meta Rating
8 Has the 3-Series become too portly, expensive, and upscale? If you think so, the 2009 BMW 1-Series might make you happier.	7.8 If you want a sprightly, track-ready sports coupe with head-turning looks and a little extra space, the 2009 Mazda RX-8 will put a smile on your face.	8.6 The 2008 BMW 3-Series sedan has the best overall driving experience in its class and remains the gold standard among mid-size sport sedans.	8.8 The Infiniti G37 Coupe is the best-selling coupe in the segment for a number of good reasons: it’s incredibly fast and handles well, and it’s good-looking in a well-heeled way.
MSRP From
$29,400	$26,435	$32,700	$34,900
Gas Mileage
17 MPG City / 28 MPG Hwy	16 MPG City / 23 MPG Hwy	14 MPG City / 30 MPG Hwy	17 MPG City / 26 MPG Hwy
Engine
Gas I6	Gas Rotary	Gas I6	Gas V6
EPA Class
Subcompact	Sub-compact	Compact	Compact
Style Name
2dr Coupe 128i	4dr Coupe Man Sport	4dr Sedan 328i RWD	2dr Base
Drivetrain
Rear Wheel Drive	Rear Wheel Drive	Rear Wheel Drive	Rear-Wheel Drive
Passenger Capacity
4	4	5	4
Passenger Doors
N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A
Body Style
2 Door Coupe	4 Door Coupe	4 Door Sedan	2 Door Coupe
Transmission
Manual	Manual w/OD	Manual	Automatic w/OD